A1 Assessment Criteria (Final version)

Demonstration of technical and visual skills

Reworking my original project plan in the light of the current crisis has meant having to be creative in how I visualise this assignment. I used black fabric as a backdrop for photographing objects from my kitchen to minimise any external context and focus attention solely on the objects. I also used an external flash offset from the camera to avoid too much direct reflection from the white bottles and glass jars.

Although the refill shop is fairly well lit I used fill-in flash to allow a higher ISO and faster shutter.

Quality of outcome

I have presented this as a slideshow to try and reinforce the idea that this is a single piece rather than a set of individual photographs.  Although the assignment brief asks for unmounted prints, the current Covid-19 situation, along with the strain on printing and delivery options, means online viewing is the most appropriate mechanism. If I were to print these I would prefer to present these as A4 images in book form.

The photographs are presented here as individual images, along with links to allow enlarging. 

Demonstration of creativity

I have placed the individual images in a larger frame with each image either to the left or right of the frame. I have presented them in pairs, with the photographs from the refill shop itself on one side and the others to act as counterpoints. For the external photographs, I looked for scenes where a single figure could be seen in the distance.

By using a tripod and shutter delay I have used myself twice here as the subject (once as customer, once as server). This meant I could get five images from the refill shop to use in this set.

Context

I had been conscious of Paul Graham’s “A Shimmer of Possibility” work while working on this, and had used his project as a model for first drafts of my final piece. Feedback from fellow students has made me re-evaluate this approach and move away from the idea of presenting these as individual images, with the photographs placed in differing locations in each frame. On second viewings this seems too contrived and too obvious as a borrowing from Graham’s work. I have kept the idea of placing the images inside a larger white frame as I am happy with the way the change of position this draws the viewers eyes to the image.

Without explicitly meaning to, I do think that my resulting work demonstrates at least in part Allan Sekula’s position that photographs do not themselves contain absolute truth, and that any interpretation is not possible without some form of context.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s